Casey’s Cookies

Casey’s Cookies Hi! I am Casey, I specialize in making custom-decorated sugar cookies under the Ohio cottage baker law. Send me a message!

Each order is thoughtfully designed and freshly made from my home kitchen to add a sweet, personal touch to your celebrations.

10/22/2026

Last week’s “oops” batch deserved a redemption round 😂🍪

***this batch does not have double butter, and is a different recipe altogether I’m trying actually

S’mores cookies with a graham cracker bottom, chocolate chip cookie dough, toasted marshmallow, and Hershey’s chocolate 🤤 No campfire required!

$4 each. Message me to claim yours! Limited supply available

Huntington updated their branding, so technically these count as fresh cookie designs—even if I just posted a Huntington...
10/21/2026

Huntington updated their branding, so technically these count as fresh cookie designs—even if I just posted a Huntington order a couple weeks ago 😂💚

10/15/2026

Only a real Disney fan will recognize the silhouettes!

These Halloween cookies are from 2 years ago, I actually really love these since I’m a Disney fanatic 😍

10/15/2026

I have an “oops” batch of s’mores cookies for sale! Twice the butter and twice the fun 😂 They spread more than planned, but I taste-tested one and can confirm… still delicious, and HUGE!

I’m practicing for this year’s Christmas cookie exchange, and thank goodness I did 😂

8 cookies available, $4 each! Message me to claim 🤎

February 2024 ➡️ today 🧸🤍Same theme, lots of practice in between! Sometimes I get so caught up in what I want to improve...
10/15/2026

February 2024 ➡️ today 🧸🤍

Same theme, lots of practice in between! Sometimes I get so caught up in what I want to improve that I forget how far I’ve come. 🥹 Thank you to everyone who has trusted me with your cookies along the way!

We can bearly wait for baby Scarlett 🤎🧸I loved making this theme with these neutral colors and a little pink thrown in 🩷...
10/14/2026

We can bearly wait for baby Scarlett 🤎🧸

I loved making this theme with these neutral colors and a little pink thrown in 🩷🤎

10/13/2026

One of my favorite cookie designs 🤍 So elegant, and it complements so many different themes! I love making each one a little different with the colors and details.

Angelo is TWO FAST!! Happy birthday Angelo! 🏎️ And here’s the same picture 3 times 😂
10/10/2026

Angelo is TWO FAST!! Happy birthday Angelo! 🏎️

And here’s the same picture 3 times 😂

Packed the swimsuits… and the icing bags 😂🐺🍪 I’ll always follow through on your orders, and I love making time for fun w...
10/08/2026

Packed the swimsuits… and the icing bags 😂🐺🍪 I’ll always follow through on your orders, and I love making time for fun with my family, too! A little cookie decorating during our downtime at Great Wolf Lodge means I get to do both 🤍

Address

Mentor, OH

Website

Alerts

Be the first to know and let us send you an email when Casey’s Cookies posts news and promotions. Your email address will not be used for any other purpose, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

Contact The Business

Send a message to Casey’s Cookies:

Shortcuts

Share

Category