08/09/2026
GLOBAL WORMING NEWS — SEPTEMBER 2026
When Your Worms Multiply: How to Know Your Bin Is Full, How to Split a Colony, and When to Start a Second Bin | Global Edition
Good morning, or Good evening wherever you are.
Every noww and then, someone writes to me in a mild panic. “My bin is a solid mass of worms.” “There must be a million of them bursting out the top.” “What do I do when there are just TOO MANY worms?”
I love these messages, because they almost always mean you’ve done something right.
Some time ago a reader named Bernie asked me exactly this, and I promised on my website that I’d one day write a proper, detailed article about worm populations — how they grow, how they settle, and what to do when your bin fills up. This is that article.
Wherever we are in the world, some of us are thinking about this too right now — just in opposite directions. Up north, the bins are at their fullest after a summer of breeding. Down south, the bins are waking up and about to surge. So this issue has something timely for all of us.
Let’s start with the part that will calm most of you down.
PART ONE — FOR EVERYONE
The good news first: a full bin is rarely an emergency
Here is the single most important thing I can tell you about worm populations, and it’s something I’ve watched hold true for more than 25 years: your worms tend to regulate themselves.
Once a colony reaches a comfortable density for its space and food, the worms quietly slow their breeding right down and hold the population steady.
A worm bin is not a goldfish that grows to the size of its tank and then bursts.
So when you look in and see a writhing mass of worms, your first job is not to act. It’s to relax. In most bins, if you did absolutely nothing, the population would settle on its own.
That said, “do nothing” isn’t always the best choice — and there’s one thing people badly mistake for overcrowding. Let’s clear that up before we do anything else.
First, rule out the impostor
If your worms are climbing the walls, gathering on the lid, or trying to escape, please do not assume the bin is overcrowded. In my experience that is rarely the real reason. Yes some of them might try and migrate out of the bin in search of greener pastures, which they rarely will find, but they will not keep multiplying until they suffocate.
Worms trying to leave are usually telling you something is wrong with the conditions, not that there are too many of them. The usual culprits are bedding that’s too wet, a sudden change in feeding, a bin that’s gone sour and airless, or a shift in the weather (worms often get restless before or during rain).
So before you split anything, check the basics.
Is the bedding damp like a wrung-out sponge, not soggy?
Does the bin smell earthy, not sour?
Have you changed anything lately?
Fix the conditions first. Nine times out of ten, the “overcrowding” walks itself back into the bedding.
Real overcrowding is calm. Escaping worms are unhappy worms. Those are two different problems.
How to tell your bin is genuinely full
Once you’ve ruled out unhappy conditions, here’s what a genuinely full, thriving bin actually looks like:
• When you lift the bedding, it’s dense with worms of every size — big mature ones, smaller young ones, and tiny hatchlings.
• Food disappears very fast. What used to take a week is gone in a day or two.
• The bin is becoming more castings than bedding. It’s getting heavy and dark.
• You can see the saddle band (the pale raised ring) on lots of your worms — that’s the sign of a mature, breeding adult.
• You spot little lemon-shaped cocoons through the bedding. That’s a colony firing on all cylinders.
As a rough benchmark, a comfortable “full house” is somewhere around a pound of worms — for every square foot / 0.092 m2 of surface area in your bin. They can pack in tighter than that, but that’s the easy number to picture.
What to do about it — four good options
When your bin is genuinely full, you have four honest choices, and none of them is difficult:
1. Do nothing. As I said, they’ll self-regulate. This is a perfectly valid answer, especially if you’re happy with how fast the bin is processing your scraps.
2. Harvest your castings. Very often a “too full” bin is really a bin that’s overdue for harvesting. Taking out the finished castings makes space, resets the balance, and gives you your black gold at the same time. Two problems, one job.
3. Split the colony and start a second bin. Take out roughly a quarter to a third of the worms and set them up in a fresh bin. Now you’ve doubled your composting power — or you’ve got a bin to give to a friend or family member and hook them on worms too.
4. Move some to the garden. You can rehouse spare worms into a shady, permanently moist part of the garden or a compost heap. One firm warning, though: compost worms are not soil worms. They need constant moisture. If that patch ever dries out completely, they will die. Only do this where you know it stays damp.
How to split a bin safely
If you go the second-bin route, here’s the gentle way to do it:
A week or so before, feed heavily on one side of the bin. Many of your worms will migrate over to that side to feast.
On the day, scoop out a dense, worm-rich portion — that’s your quarter to a third.
Set up the new bin first: fresh moist bedding, and a good handful of the old bin’s castings mixed in. That familiar, living material carries the microbes your worms already know, and it gives them somewhere to hide while they settle. It genuinely lowers their stress in the new home.
Keep both bins nicely moist, and feed lightly for the first week or two while everyone settles. Don’t overload a freshly split bin — let them find their feet first.
That’s the whole method. It’s forgiving. Worms want to live.
NORTHERN HEMISPHERE —
Your bins are at peak population
Northern friends, your bins are as full as they’ll be all year right now. A whole summer of warmth and steady feeding has your colony at its breeding peak, and you’re heading into your productive autumn stretch, when worms stay active and hungry as the days cool.
This makes September your natural moment to make a decision about all those worms — but timing matters, so read this carefully.
If you want to split, do it now, early. A brand-new bin needs a few weeks of decent warmth to establish before the cold sets in. Split in early autumn and the new colony has time to settle and build up before winter. Split too late, in the first cold snap, and you’re asking a small, thinly-populated bin to survive winter with little thermal mass and little volume of bedding and castings in the bin— that’s a hard start.
If it’s already turning cold where you are, don’t split — harvest instead. Pull your castings, make space that way, and hold the split until spring. Your worms will happily overwinter as one strong, dense colony. A packed bin actually holds its warmth better through the cold.
Feed a little more generously while they’re still active, then ease off as the temperature drops and they slow down. A full bin going into winter is a well-fed. it is always advisable to, insulate your bin if there is a danger of freezing temperatures around the corner.
The short version: split early, or wait for spring. Don’t split into the cold.
SOUTHERN HEMISPHERE —
Your bins are waking up for the surge
Southern friends, we’re on the opposite side of the year, and honestly, we’ve got the easier hand this month.
Your bins are waking from the cool season. The worms are getting active again, appetite is returning, and the spring breeding surge is just ahead. Your population is about to climb.
This is the prime window to split or start a second bin. If you set up a new colony now, it has the entire warm season in front of it to establish, fill out, and thrive. A spring split is the strongest split you can make all year.
Plan your second bin before the surge, not after. It’s much easier to divide a calm, waking colony now than to scramble when the bin is suddenly overflowing in a month or two. Get the new bin ready — bedding moist, a handful of old castings in — so you can move worms the moment they’re active.
Watch your moisture as it warms. Spring warmth and wind dry bedding out faster than you expect after the cool season. Keep checking that wrung-out-sponge feel, especially near the surface.
A personal note: I’m still in Germany as I write this, flying back to Cape Town at the end of next week. I’m expecting to find my own bins stirring and hungry when I get home, and I’ll tell you next month what I actually see when I lift the lids. That’s the honest part of this work — I report what’s really in front of me, not what a chart says should be there.
PART TWO — FOR EVERYONE
Did you know?
That pale, saddle-shaped band you see on some of your worms — it’s called the clitellum, and it only appears once a worm is sexually mature and ready to breed. So next time you’re in the bin, glance at how many of your worms are wearing the saddle. The more saddles, the more breeding power your colony has right now. It’s a quick, free way to read your bin’s future.
Your quick win this week
Take two minutes at your next feeding and go looking for cocoons — the little lemon- or teardrop-shaped capsules tucked in the bedding, usually pale and about the size of a match head. Finding them means your conditions are right and your colony is renewing itself. It’s one of the most reassuring things you can see in a worm bin.
Over to you
Have you ever split a bin, or given a starter colony to a friend or grandchild? I’d love to hear how it went — the wins and the mishaps both. Just reply to this email; I read every one, and your stories often shape a future issue.
Next month
In October we’ll look at feeding through the changing seasons — how much to feed, and what to adjust, as your bin heats up or cools down on either side of the world. (Topics can shift if something more urgent lands in my inbox, but that’s the plan.)
Until then, wherever you are: keep it moist, keep it earthy, and don’t panic about a full bin. It means you’re doing this right.
Happy worming,
Stephan
PS: There are quite a few ways to successfully manage worm bins. The methods I am sharing with you are the ones that I have applied for a long time. I don't claim that they are the best or the only ones. If you have different methods to successfully recycle your organic waste with compost worms, I congratulate you and wish you all the best and loads of healthy worms and wonderful worm castings for the years to come.