10/01/2026
Even if you disagree with the conclusions drawn from the videos -- even if you believe there is some justification for what Ross did -- all Americans should agree on this: An American citizen being gunned down in the street by a federal agent deserves a fair and impartial investigation.
Renee Nicole Good deserves justice. Her wife Rebecca, who watched her die and collapsed in the snow covered in her blood, deserves answers. Her three children deserve the truth.
"That's fine, dude. I'm not mad at you."
Those were Renee Nicole Good's last words to ICE agent Jonathan Ross -- the man who would shoot her in the head 26 seconds later.
"F*cking b*tch."
Those were Ross' first words as Renee lay dead or dying in her car.
On Friday, a new video emerged with footage from Ross' own cellphone, which he was holding throughout the encounter. The Trump administration rushed to share it, with JD Vance posting it as supposed proof that Ross "fired in self defense" and that "his life was endangered."
The video shows nothing of the sort.
What it actually shows is a woman speaking calmly and kindly to the officer who would end her life moments later. Not a crazed provocateur. Not a "violent rioter." Not someone who "weaponized her vehicle" to "kill federal agents," as DHS spokesperson Tricia McLaughlin claimed. Not someone committing "an act of domestic terrorism," as Kristi Noem alleged.
It shows a woman who, when masked agents surrounded her car and began screaming orders and yanking at her door, made a decision to leave a frightening, rapidly escalating situation. And was killed for it.
Some will point to the moments before the shooting and ask: Why didn't she just comply? Why did she drive away? Her wife even said "drive, baby, drive" -- doesn't that make them partially responsible?
Let's be clear about what that argument is actually saying: that a mother deserved to be shot in the head for trying to leave.
Yes, Renee chose to drive away. Yes, Rebecca -- watching masked men surround her wife's car, yank at the door handle, and scream "get out of the f*cking car" -- urged her to go. And yes, Rebecca later sobbed to a witness, "It's my fault" -- the anguished cry of a woman covered in her wife's blood and brain matter, not a confession of wrongdoing.
But here's what cannot be forgotten: Just twenty seconds before the shooting, Rebecca had told Ross directly, "We don't change our plates every morning, just so you know. It'll be the same plate when you come talk to us later." She even added: "U.S. citizen. Former f*cking veteran."
Ross had recorded them. They had Renee's plates. They could find out where she lived -- blocks away. If agents wanted to charge her with obstruction or any other offense, they could have followed up. This confrontation did not need to happen in the street. They could have de-escalated, as any competent officer is trained to do. They chose not to.
And even if you believe Renee made the wrong choice by driving away -- even if you think she should have sat there while aggressive masked men screamed at her and grabbed at her door -- disobeying an order is not a capital offense. There is no crime in America for which the punishment is summary ex*****on by a federal agent. Not fleeing. Not "impeding." Not failing to comply fast enough with screamed commands.
To those who would say she "f*cked around and found out" -- this is America, not a war zone. "FAFO" is not a legal doctrine. It is not in the Constitution. It is not in any law enforcement manual. It is the language of thugs and authoritarians who believe that agents of the state have the right to kill citizens for disobedience. They do not.
This is not opinion. This is standard law enforcement training. This is DHS's own policy.
Eric Balliet, a retired ICE agent with 25 years of experience who was himself injured in a vehicular assault in 2008, reviewed the footage for CBS News. His conclusion was unambiguous: "If someone is fleeing, that is not a justification for the use of deadly force."
And the extensive video evidence -- captured from multiple angles by bystanders and neighbors -- confirms what actually happened in those final seconds.
As Renee begins to move her car, she turns her steering wheel to the right -- away from Ross, not toward him. Every independent analysis agrees: The New York Times, The Washington Post, ABC News, and CBS News all conducted frame-by-frame reviews and reached the same conclusion. She was trying to go around him. She was trying to get away.
Ross had positioned himself near the front of the vehicle -- a decision that Balliet called reckless and provocative. "I don't understand the tactical or law enforcement advantage of someone on foot in front of a moving, running or occupied vehicle," he said. "You're almost inducing a shooting if that person decides to flee."
But even having made that reckless choice, Ross was not trapped. As the car begins to move, he steps aside. He is no longer in its path.
And that is the moment he chooses to fire -- shooting into the car as it passes him, striking Renee in the head and killing her.
His first words after shooting a woman in the head? "F*cking bitch."
Uninjured -- as multiple videos confirm -- Ross walks over to Renee's car, now crashed against a utility pole. He looks at her bloody body. Then he turns around. Still filming. Instead of keeping his hands free as standard law enforcement practice requires, he had never once during the entire encounter put his phone down -- not when he approached her car, not when he positioned himself in front of it, not when he drew his weapon, not when he fired three shots into a fleeing vehicle.
Less than a minute later, he gets in his car and leaves what is now an active crime scene.
Former GOP Rep. Adam Kinzinger, no liberal, reacted to the footage: "So an officer has his phone out recording obviously distracted, shoots a woman and calls her a 'f'ing Bitch' and they think that HELPS the case?!?"
So here we are. A 37-year-old woman -- a mother of three -- is dead. Whether you call it a killing or a murder, the reality is the same.
An American citizen is gone because of the recklessness of an ICE agent who made all the wrong choices. He chose to escalate. He chose to position himself in front of a car. And most damningly, he chose to fire at a woman who was driving away from him.
The Trump administration has spent virtually every moment since Renee's death attempting to smear her reputation and spin an endless web of lies. They have called her a "domestic terrorist," a "violent rioter," a "professional agitator." They have claimed she "violently, willfully, and viciously ran over" an officer who is visible on video walking away uninjured moments after shooting her.
Trump himself doubled down on Friday, spreading conspiracy theories that Renee was part of a shadowy "leftwing network" trying to "incite violence." His most unhinged remarks, however, were reserved for the witnesses to her killing. One bystander, having watched Ross quickly glance at Renee's mangled body and then rapidly return to his car to drive away from the scene, screamed "shame" at him repeatedly.
To Trump, this was not a normal human reaction to witnessing the horror of a woman being shot point blank in the head -- it was evidence she was a "paid agitator." He seemed genuinely baffled that anyone would react so emotionally. He even complained that her horrified screaming made the video inconvenient to watch: "The news sort of turned her down, turned her off because you're trying to watch -- she was so loud and so crazy and just not normal."
"When somebody sees something like that," Trump chillingly mused, as if reviewing a performance, "they don't go screaming and screaming, and the same words. So, I guess you could say, professional, but I didn’t think she did a very good job.”
Then there is JD Vance, who has been perhaps the most vile in his attacks. He called Renee's death "a tragedy of her own making" and claimed she had been "brainwashed" by "left-wing ideology." He described her as a "deranged leftist." And in a moment that revealed the full moral bankruptcy of this administration, Vance declared that her killer -- the man who shot her in the head and called her a "f*cking b*tch" -- "deserves a debt of gratitude."
Vance then made the administration's intentions explicit: there would be no accountability. He declared that the officer is "protected by absolute immunity" and was "just doing his job" -- effectively announcing that the administration has already decided the outcome of any investigation or potential prosecution before it has even begun. This assertion has been broadly debunked by legal experts.
Former Hennepin County Attorney Michael Freeman, who filed criminal charges against Derek Chauvin over the murder of George Floyd, told CNN bluntly: "The vice president is wrong. We have a rogue officer acting in a malicious way that killed a 37-year-old woman in cold blood. He had no reason to fear for his life. And I believe he will be prosecuted successfully in state court."
Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro, a former attorney general, also responded to him directly: "[Vance] is profoundly and pathetically a weak human being. What we need right now is not idiotic gaslighting from the sitting vice president of the United States, but a thorough investigation."
But a thorough investigation is exactly what this administration is blocking. The FBI "reversed course" just hours after agreeing to a joint investigation with Minnesota, shutting out state investigators entirely and seizing sole control of all case materials, scene evidence, and witness interviews.
This is a striking departure from standard practice -- including the FBI's own policy, which states that state and local agencies are "not subordinate to the FBI" and that investigative resources are typically "pooled in a common effort."
The Trump administration wants to keep the investigation internal -- where they can control the evidence, control access to witnesses, and control the story that emerges.
If the administration truly believed their self-defense narrative would hold up to scrutiny, they would welcome independent validation. Instead, they are doing everything in their power to prevent it. Innocent people don't block investigations. As Governor Walz observed, Noem has made herself "judge, jury and ex*****oner."
Even if you disagree with the conclusions drawn from the videos -- even if you believe there is some justification for what Ross did -- all Americans should agree on this: An American citizen being gunned down in the street by a federal agent deserves a fair and impartial investigation.
Renee Nicole Good deserves justice. Her wife Rebecca, who watched her die and collapsed in the snow covered in her blood, deserves answers. Her three children deserve the truth.
Renee went outside to watch over her neighbors. She smiled at the man who would kill her and said, "I'm not mad at you."
He shot her in the head and called her a "f*cking bitch."
Renee deserved better. America deserves better.
Call your elected officials. Demand accountability. Demand a real investigation -- not a cover-up run by the same people who lied about it within hours.
Call your representative at (202) 224-3121. Demand they cosponsor the articles of impeachment being filed against Kristi Noem.
Over 1,000 protests demanding justice for Renee are being held across the country this weekend -- to find one in your area, visit https://tinyurl.com/yeyffdp8
To help Renee's wife and son at this terrible time, there is a GoFundMe campaign at https://www.gofundme.com/f/support-for-renee-goods-wife-and-son
----
To view the newly released video from Ross' cellphone, visit https://www.facebook.com/reel/1459236089323487
For a very comprehensive compilation of the many witness videos taken of the scene before, during, and after Renee's killing that offers a clear and definitive analysis of how events unfolded, step by step, at https://www.nytimes.com/video/us/100000010631041/minneapolis-ice-shooting-video.html?smid=url-share
For the CBS expert video analysis: https://www.cbsnews.com/minnesota/news/ice-shooting-minneapolis-retired-agent-video-analysis/
To read more about how the Trump administration is blocking Minnesota officials from investigating Renee's murder, visit https://www.nytimes.com/2026/01/08/us/minnesota-ice-shooting-news.html?unlocked_article_code=1.C1A.l2gW.DhSTc_7vPV94&smid=url-share
----
For books for children and teens about the importance of standing up for truth, decency, and justice, even in dark times, visit our blog post, "Dissent Is Patriotic: 50 Books About Women Who Fought for Change," at https://www.amightygirl.com/blog?p=14364
For books for tweens and teens about girls living under real-life authoritarian regimes throughout history that will help them appreciate how precious democracy truly is, visit our blog post "The Fragility of Freedom: Mighty Girl Books About Life Under Authoritarianism" at https://www.amightygirl.com/blog?p=32426
To stay connected with A Mighty Girl, you can sign-up for A Mighty Girl's free email newsletter at https://www.amightygirl.com/forms/newsletter